Before Pilate

Mark 15:1-15.  This sermon was preached by Pastor Marty Bonner on February 28, 2021.

I am using the title Before Pilate with double-meaning.  Jesus was literally brought before Pilate who was the Roman governor, or better, prefect of Judea.  As the chief executive officer of Rome on the scene, Jesus was in Pilate’s hands and at his mercy.

However, Jesus is no mere man.  He is the eternal Word of God who had stepped down from the heavens into this world, taking on the nature of a human.  In this sense, Jesus is before Pilate in several other ways.  Jesus existed long before Pilate was ever born.  He was the eternal Son of God and Word of God, present with the Father before Creation began.  Thus, Jesus is before Pilate in time.

Jesus is also of a higher kingdom and authority than Pilate could ever be.  Thus, Jesus is before him in rank and station.  In fact, one day Pilate will be brought before Jesus and judged for his actions.  As the Scriptures tell us, God the Father has appointed Jesus as the judge of all who are alive and all who have died (Acts 10:42).  In 1 Peter 4:3-6, we are warned that the judgments of men only affect the flesh, but all men will stand before Jesus and give account for their life.  His judgment affects us eternally.

Jesus is brought before Pilate

We mentioned in previous sermons that there are actually 4 different events in the trial of Jesus.  He is first brought before Annas who is a previous High Priest while Caiaphas has the elders gathered.  Then, Jesus appears before Caiaphas and the Sanhedrin.  The third meeting is only briefly mentioned and is what we have here in verse 1.  Up until now, everything has happened in the middle of the night.  The acts of the council must be done during the day in order to be official.  This third meeting seems to be a pro forma meeting in which the proceedings of the earlier interrogations and the gathering of witnesses is rubber stamped.

The real problem for the leaders is that Rome has stripped them of the power of capital punishment over their own people.  They want to execute Jesus, but they have to get Rome, Pilate, to do it for them.  Thus, shortly after dawn, they bring Jesus to the Praetorium, the headquarters of Pilate’s administration in Jerusalem.

Mark’s account is somewhat disordered in regard to a linear timeline, though it is not disordered in the sense of giving us an understanding of what happened in general.  These cultures were not as concerned with timelines as we are in the West today.  In the other Gospels, we are told that the priests bring Jesus to the Praetorium, but they cannot go in.  It would ceremonially defile them and disqualify them from participating in the Passover later.  Pilate comes outside and Jesus is formally charged by the elders.  Some questioning takes place outside, but then Pilate brings Jesus inside of the Praetorium to question him without the Jewish leaders.  Eventually they end up back outside for Pilate’s official decision.  Mark’s goal is not to establish an exact account of all that our inquisitive minds might want to know.  Rather, it is to establish the important facts of what happened. No charges are listed in Mark, but in Luke 23, we are told some of the charges made against him.

First, they say that the caught Jesus perverting, or twisting, the nation.  This is a general accusation and begs the question, “What was he twisting them towards?”  The second charge makes this specific.  They charge Jesus with forbidding people to pay taxes to Caesar.  This is a lie.  Just that week, Jesus had publicly declared that the Jews should give to Caesar what belongs to Caesar and to God what belongs to God.  Regardless, if it was true, Rome would have a vested interest in stamping out such influence.  The third charge is that Jesus says that he is the Messiah that Israel had been waiting for, which is to be the king of Israel.  Of course, these charges have nothing to do with why they want him dead.  Their real charge is that Jesus has blasphemed by claiming to be God.  However, such a religious charge would have no weight with Pilate, so it is left off.  Even with that, the real offense of Jesus is this: he testified that their deeds were evil, and they were too proud to repent.

Of course, we can infer the last charge from Mark’s description of Pilate’s question.  “Are you the king of the Jews?”  Kingship in Israel had been a messy topic ever since the exile.  They had been under the thumb of Persia, then Greece, and then Rome.  During this period, they were ruled by governors in general.  Even under the brief freedom of the Maccabees, they had been led by priests.  Herod the Great was appointed king of Judea by Caesar in 36 BC up to his death a couple of years after the death of Jesus.  However, Herod the Great was not of the lineage of David.  He had no right to the throne biblically.  After his death, the administration of Jerusalem quickly fell apart under Herod’s sons and Rome placed a governor over it.  If anyone was claiming to be the rightful king of Israel, and even the prophesied Messiah-figure, Rome would be keenly interested.

Before we get into the answer of Jesus, let’s look at his response overall.  In general, Jesus is not answering the charges against him.  Isaiah 53:7 says, “He was oppressed and he was afflicted, yet he opened not his mouth; he was led as a lamb to the slaughter, and as a sheep before its shearers is silent, so he opened not his mouth.”  Jesus had come to die, and he came to do it in a way that was not that of an arrogant, loud rebel.  How hard it would be to stand before godless men who are making baseless charges against you, and to simply trust God as your defense.

It is not that we should never defend ourselves in any way.  Jesus was fulfilling Scripture.  He needed to be silent before his accusers in general.  There is a time and a place for making a defense.  We see this in the New Testament with the Apostles, especially Paul.  However, we must never defend ourselves in such a way that we are desperate to get free.  Would I lie to get free?  Would I tell the truth about others to ingratiate myself to those who are charging me?  Would I use the time to vent and rage against injustice?  These are not the ways of Christ.

Yet, his is not an absolute silence.  Jesus does give an answer to Pilate, but it is a cryptic one.  Jesus literally says, “You are saying it.”  This is an acceptance that implies there is more to the story.  It is not a definite, “I am the king of Judea!”  In John 18, we are given more of the exchange between Pilate and Jesus.

“Are you the King of the Jews?” ³⁴ Jesus answered, “Do you say this of your own accord, or did others say it to you about me?” ³⁵ Pilate answered, “Am I a Jew? Your own nation and the chief priests have delivered you over to me. What have you done?” ³⁶ Jesus answered, “My kingdom is not of this world. If my kingdom were of this world, my servants would have been fighting, that I might not be delivered over to the Jews. But my kingdom is not from the world.” ³⁷ Then Pilate said to him, “So you are a king?” Jesus answered, “You say that I am a king. For this purpose I was born and for this purpose I have come into the world—to bear witness to the truth. Everyone who is of the truth listens to my voice.” ³⁸ Pilate said to him, “What is truth?”

Clearly, Jesus takes some time to interact with Pilate, most likely because Pilate is unwittingly caught up in something that is a great evil and he could not begin to understand it.

Pilate comes to the decision that Jesus is not guilty of anything other than annoying the religious leaders.  He does not what to become their lackey in this matter.  I want to note a couple of other details that Mark leaves out.  We are told that Pilate’s wife had been tormented with troubling dreams.  She actually sent word to Pilate while he was sitting in judgment, saying not to have anything to do with this Jesus affair.  Later, Pilate would publicly wash his hands in front of the people and declare, “I am innocent of this man’s blood; see to it yourselves.” (Matthew 27:24 ESV). 

Mark does tell us that Pilate tried to release Jesus through a custom that had been established.  Every year at Passover, he would release a prisoner as a show of good faith to the Jews and in recognition of their holy day.  We don’t have much details on this custom, but in this case, Pilate puts the judgment in the hands of the people by giving them a choice between two prisoners.  Perhaps he feels that this is a way of blocking the religious leaders.  If Jesus is only guilty of ticking off the leaders then the people will probably spare him.  Thus, Pilate finds a prisoner who had been involved in a rebellion that ended in murder.  Of whom, we do not know.  This sets the crowd and the religious leaders up for a classic choice.

Barabbas or Jesus?  I can’t be coincidence that the name Barabbas is Aramaic for “son of the father.”  This choice becomes a metaphor for all that is happening spiritually.  Will we choose Jesus who is the Son of God the Father, or will we choose Barabbas who is spiritually a son of a different father, the devil?  It reminds me of the prophecy that Jesus gave the religious leaders in John 5:43. “I have come in my Father’s name, and you do not receive me; if another comes in his own name, him you will receive.”

In short, as a nation, Israel would reject Jesus as the Christ and later accept another who would not be the true Christ.  This other does not come in the name of God the Father.  He comes in his own name.  He is the anti-Messiah, the antichrist.  God works hard by His Spirit and through His prophets to get us to have a love of the truth, so that we will be prepared when we reach such moments of decision.  These moments are extremely critical choices that represented true spiritual state at the time.  In essence, we are choosing between good and evil, Jesus and Satan, God and the world.  O, how deceived people can become when they rebuff the attempts of God to give them a love of the truth.  On that day, the One who is the Truth stood before them.  Barabbas or Jesus?

If Pilate thought his actions would thwart the religious leaders, he was mistaken.  The crowd is stirred up by the chief priests to call for the release of Barabbas and the death of Jesus.  “Give us Barabbas,” they cried.  “What shall I do with Jesus?” Pilate retorted.  “Crucify Him,” they shouted over and over.  As the crowd is worked into a frenzy, Pilate realizes that it is better for this one man to die than to risk a bloody crushing of what would soon become an uprising.  Caesar would not be happy with such maladministration.  His abilities would be questioned and his position lost.

It is sad that those who are supposed to represent God can be some of the worst at stirring up others against His work.  How blind must those blind guides have been?  Do we not have blind guides in our own day?  How careful Christian leaders must be in the exercise of their authority, and how careful Christians must be in those they allow to be over them.  Guard your heart, friend, for out of it flows the course of your life.

At this point, Pilate yields, and, in true Roman form, we can say that the die is cast.  He orders Jesus to be crucified. 

We must understand that there is no going back.  There is only going forward.  This is our condemnation; the light came into the world and the world loved darkness rather than the light because their deeds were evil.  Our generation is not any different than that generation.  We too are an evil generation that pompously puts the followers of Jesus on public trial all the time.  We too have religious leaders who pretend to stand for God, but lead in opposition to Jesus.  They would crucify him in a second, if he appeared now in the same way that he did then.  However, Jesus is not coming back in the same way he came the first time.

When Jesus comes back, he will come as the One who is worthy to judge the living and the dead.  He will do so not in some sort of cosmic revenge, but in a sad recognition that no matter how much you love some, they want their wickedness more than they want you.  In fact, they will hate you just for existing because your existence reminds them of their wicked heart.

The die is cast, but believers in Jesus those who love God and are loved by Him, will hold fast their faith in Him, regardless of what lies ahead.  We know just how the cube will land and just who will be left standing in the end!

Before Pilate audio